Compliance Department · Annual review

The Approved Pantry.

Every jar below has met the legal minimum of 90% peanut and has been found to be, in the words of our auditors, "peanut butter." Approval is not transferable to almonds.

Links go to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, which is reinvested directly into peanuts.

✓ APPROVED · INGREDIENTS: PEANUTS

Crazy Richard's 100% Peanuts

One ingredient. The Board read the label and wept.

View on Amazon →
✓ APPROVED · CREAMY DIVISION

Jif Creamy

The East Coast standard. Consistent, smooth, unbothered.

View on Amazon →
✓ APPROVED · CRUNCHY DIVISION

Skippy Super Chunk

Recommended for our West Coast shareholders and anyone who wants to hear their sandwich.

View on Amazon →
✓ APPROVED · STIR REQUIRED

Smucker's Natural

The oil separates. So does society. Stir both.

View on Amazon →
✓ APPROVED · DARK ROAST

Santa Cruz Organic Dark Roasted

For shareholders who like their peanuts with a little more conviction.

View on Amazon →
✓ APPROVED · EQUIPMENT

A Natural Peanut Butter Stirrer

Mixes the oil back in without the forearm workout. The only gadget our Board has ever endorsed.

View on Amazon →
✗ NOT APPROVED · UNDER PERMANENT REVIEW

Almond Butter (all brands)

28.7 gallons per ounce. The Compliance Department has closed this file and will not be reopening it.